Carroll Place, Staten Island: Grade D · 311 & City Data
Grade D, 39 out of 100. How does Carroll Place in Staten Island rank for traffic safety, noise, and cleanliness?
Livability score
Grade D, livability 39 out of 100.
Calm 39, ranked against quiet residential streets. Access 38, ranked against every street in the city. More complaints per home than most quiet residential streets, and little within a walk.
That puts Carroll Place in the bottom 16% of scored streets citywide.
Strongest on street crime (77) and tree cover (54). Quietness (2) is the weak spot.
On the record
More 311 reports on Carroll Place name street/sidewalk noise than any other category, 36 of them, and the block ranks in the louder half of quiet residential streets. Street/sidewalk noise accounts for 50% of the 72 reports on file here. Abandoned vehicle follows with 17 reports, and illegal parking with 16. Reports on Carroll Place span 18 distinct 311 categories. The 311 file works out to about 180 reports for every 100 homes on Carroll Place.
The HPD file on Carroll Place holds no Class C violation, the tier the city treats as an immediate health or safety risk. 16 residential buildings on Carroll Place hold the 40 homes on file, 2 of them walk-up apartment buildings and 0 of them buildings with an elevator. That averages about 2.5 homes to a building.
No one has been injured in a reported crash here since 2021.
Against quiet residential streets, cleanliness comes in at 52, with parking at 11. An 11 on parking places Carroll Place in the weakest quarter of quiet residential streets. Infrastructure ranks 19 on the same scale, with housing at 18. Transit ranks 40 and food nearby 23, both against every street in the city rather than inside the band. Of the three measures ranked citywide, tree cover is the strongest on Carroll Place, at 54. Carroll Place is ranked against about 1,970 quiet residential streets citywide.
The strongest band-ranked measure on Carroll Place is traffic safety, at 63.
None of the 40 homes on file are rent-stabilized.
Scores are built from 311 complaints, HPD violations, NYPD crash records, NYPD felony complaint records, MTA stop locations, DOHMH food permits, and the street tree census, divided by the homes and businesses on the street, updated weekly. Read the scoring method or the data sources.
Nearest streets in Staten Island
- Westervelt Avenue, Staten Island
- Hamilton Avenue, Staten Island
- Curtis Place, Staten Island
- Crescent Avenue, Staten Island
- Belmont Place, Staten Island
- Street Marks Place, Staten Island
Carroll Place runs through St. George, where every scored street in the neighborhood is ranked beside it.
Every scored street in Staten Island, the citywide rankings of all 5,700+ graded streets, or Brooklyn vs Staten Island: How the Two Boroughs Score (2026 Data).