Staten Island's Quietest Streets, and What They Cost You

Best streets & avenues in Staten Island, the quietest borough in our data

Based on 1,502 streets
1502
Streets & Avenues Listed
49
Avg Score
Updated: Sep 8, 2026

About Top Staten Island Streets & Avenues

Staten Island posts the best quietness average in the city, 58, and the best traffic-safety average, a fraction ahead of Manhattan's. Both are counted against the number of people on each street, so this is a real result rather than the low-density discount our old per-kilometer score handed out for free. What the island pays for it is total. It has the weakest walkable-food readings in the city and shares the weakest transit readings with Queens, and since roughly a third of the score is what a street can reach on foot, the borough finishes third overall at 49. The clearest illustration is Todt Hill Road, the mansion road on the ridge, which scores 32 on a traffic-safety reading of zero with nothing inside a walk of it. Roughly 1,500 scored Staten Island streets produce a handful of A grades. If quiet is what you are buying, this list is the right place to shop. Read the access columns before you commit.

Have you been to these streets or avenues?

Share your experience by voting on streets and avenues you know. Your vote helps others make informed decisions about NYC neighborhoods.

Vote on Streets & Avenues

Explore More Categories

How We Rank These Streets

Rankings are built from 5M+ NYC 311 complaints, HPD violation records and NYPD crash records, counted against the people who live on each street and ranked against streets of the same kind.

Updated daily from NYC Open Data
Streets with <5 data points excluded
Learn more about our methodology →